Decoded: The CIA's Secret Files on Crop Circles & Alien Communication Revealed
In 1974, scientists embarked on an extraordinary endeavor, transmitting a message into deep space using the powerful Arecibo radio telescope. This binary-coded communication, directed towards stars in the Hercules constellation, was primarily a technological demonstration rather than a genuine attempt at extraterrestrial contact. The transmission contained basic information about Earth and human life, created by a team led by Dr. Frank Drake with input from Carl Sagan.
What began as a ceremonial exercise took an unexpected turn 27 years later when an apparent response arrived. This incident connects to a broader phenomenon of mysterious patterns appearing in fields worldwide - crop circles. These formations, ranging from simple circles to complex geometric designs, have been documented throughout history, from medieval accounts to modern investigations. While many debate their origins and meanings, these patterns continue to fascinate researchers seeking to understand potential communications from beyond our understanding.
Key Takeaways
The 1974 Arecibo Message was transmitted into space as a technological demonstration, with a surprising response received 27 years later.
Crop circles have appeared throughout recorded history, with documented cases dating back centuries across multiple continents.
The phenomenon of crop formations is characterized by intricate patterns created rapidly, often overnight, and frequently associated with unusual light activity.
The Arecibo Message of 1974
In 1974, scientists harnessed the power of the world's most advanced radio telescope to beam a carefully crafted message into deep space. This binary-coded transmission was directed toward a dense star cluster in the Hercules constellation, approximately 25,000 light-years from Earth.
The message was primarily a technological demonstration, showcasing humanity's growing capabilities in radio astronomy. No one genuinely expected an extraterrestrial civilization to receive or respond to the transmission, at least not within human lifetimes.
Dr. Frank Drake led the team that developed the message, with notable contributions from Carl Sagan. The transmission consisted of 1,679 binary digits designed to be arranged into a visual image when properly interpreted.
The message included several key components:
A number sequence (1-10) providing a decoding key
Atomic numbers for hydrogen, carbon, nitrogen, oxygen, and phosphorus—the building blocks of life on Earth
Information about human civilization
The scientists set the transmission frequency to 2380 MHz and aimed the powerful Arecibo radio telescope toward its distant target. After the ceremonial broadcast, the team celebrated their achievement and continued with their scientific work.
Remarkably, 27 years after this interstellar message was sent, unexpected developments occurred related to the original transmission. These subsequent events have continued to intrigue researchers and the public alike, adding an unexpected chapter to what was originally intended as a purely symbolic demonstration.
The Unexpected Reply 27 Years Later
In 1974, a group of scientists transmitted a message into deep space using the Arecibo radio telescope. The transmission, directed toward a star cluster in the Hercules constellation, was primarily a ceremonial demonstration of new radio astronomy technology. No one expected a response, especially considering the nearest star in the broadcast direction was 25,000 light-years away.
The message itself was elegantly simple - a binary code designed to describe Earth and humanity to any intelligent life that might intercept it. Dr. Frank Drake led the team that created the message, with assistance from Carl Sagan. The transmission included representations of basic numbers, atomic structures of elements essential to life, and other fundamental information about our world.
After sending the message at 2380 MHz, the scientists congratulated each other and continued with their careers. The exercise was complete, and any potential response would take tens of thousands of years to arrive, if ever.
Yet remarkably, just 27 years later, something unexpected happened. In 2001, a crop formation appeared in a field that seemed to directly respond to the 1974 transmission. The pattern resembled the original Arecibo message but contained subtle differences that suggested it was a reply rather than a mere copy.
Crop formations have been documented throughout history, from 9th century France to 17th century England. Historical records often associate these patterns with unusual lights or phenomena. The 2001 formation stood out because it contained what appeared to be intelligible communication rather than abstract patterns.
This particular formation was significant for several reasons:
It specifically mirrored the structure of the Arecibo message
It included modifications that could be interpreted as a response
It appeared to use the same binary communication system
While many crop formations remain mysterious in origin and meaning, this one seemed to transcend the usual geometric patterns. For researchers studying potential extraterrestrial communication, this formation represented an extraordinary possibility - that someone or something had received our message and found a way to reply.
The appearance of this formation raised profound questions about who might be responding and how they could have received a message that hadn't yet reached its intended destination. Some researchers proposed alternative explanations, including human creation, while others maintained that the timing and complexity suggested something more unusual was occurring.
Y Files Sponsorship by Hule
The Y Files secured a notable partnership with Hule, a company specializing in high-protein, low-sugar plant-based meals. Their products feature 27 essential vitamins and minerals along with an easily digestible source of fiber.
During a recent episode, the host demonstrated Hule's products while visiting a Shaolin Temple. The monks at the temple enthusiastically embraced the meals, appreciating their taste, environmental sustainability, and affordability.
Viewers interested in trying Hule can visit my.u.com/yfiles to receive special benefits with their first order:
Free shipping
Complimentary Hule T-shirt
Get Started Guide
The host particularly highlighted Hule's "Hot and Savory" line, which proved popular among the monks before their chanting practice. According to the testimonial, the monks appreciated having access to nutritious meals that helped maintain their energy levels during demanding spiritual exercises.
Hule's emphasis on balanced nutrition aligns with the philosophical elements explored in the Y Files, creating a natural partnership between the brand and the show's investigative themes.
Shaolin Temple and Personal Chi Reset
Monks at the Shaolin Temple have found a new way to maintain balance through high-protein, plant-based nutrition. During a visit to the ancient temple, practitioners discovered that many fellow monks faced dietary and energy challenges.
The temple environment requires both physical and spiritual nourishment. Monks participate in regular chanting practices and need stable blood sugar levels to maintain focus and discipline.
Despite popular misconceptions, these monks don't maintain vows of silence. The traditional media portrayal of completely silent monastics doesn't match reality at Shaolin, where communication plays an important role in community life.
Proper nutrition has become central to maintaining what practitioners call the "chi zone" - a state of energetic balance. This balance is essential for the monks' daily practices, which combine meditation with physical training.
The monks have embraced plant-based meals rich in essential nutrients. These meals provide:
27 essential vitamins and minerals
High protein content
Low sugar formulation
Substantial fiber intake
As one temple visitor observed: "A man who does not eat enough fiber may soon find himself trying to pass a camel through a keyhole." This colorful expression highlights the practical health concerns that exist alongside spiritual practices.
The integration of modern nutrition with ancient practices demonstrates how the Shaolin tradition continues to evolve. The monks appreciate meals that are not only nutritionally complete but also environmentally sustainable and economical.
When mealtime approaches, the normally disciplined environment becomes energetic. "This group gets rowdy when the blood sugar drops," noted one regular visitor who helps coordinate the community meals.
Introduction to Buddha Buddies and Hule
In 1974, scientists sent a binary message into space using a powerful radio telescope aimed at the Hercules constellation. This transmission, known as the Arecibo Message, was primarily ceremonial with little expectation of response, given that the nearest star in that direction is 25,000 light-years away.
Twenty-seven years later, an unexpected development occurred. The narrative shifts to a monastery where "Buddha Buddies" have formed a unique community. These monks, contrary to popular stereotypes, are quite vocal and energetic.
The Buddha Buddies were introduced to Hule (stylized as "hu"), a plant-based meal solution that provides 27 essential vitamins and minerals with ample fiber. This high-protein, low-sugar option has become popular among the monastery residents for its taste, environmental benefits, and affordability.
The monks appreciate the practical benefits of Hule products, particularly the "Hot and Savory" variety that helps maintain their energy levels before their chanting practices. Despite their spiritual focus, these monks display vibrant personalities, breaking the stereotype of silent, reserved religious practitioners.
Hule serves as an important nutritional component for the Buddha Buddies, helping them maintain both physical health and spiritual balance. Their communal meals become occasions for nourishing both body and soul, reflecting their holistic approach to wellbeing.
Benefits of Hule
Hule offers a comprehensive nutritional solution for those seeking balance in their diet and lifestyle. This plant-based meal option contains 27 essential vitamins and minerals, making it an excellent choice for complete nutrition. The high protein, low sugar formulation helps maintain steady energy levels throughout the day, preventing the energy crashes often associated with less balanced meals.
Fiber is a standout component of Hule products. The ample fiber content supports digestive health and promotes regularity—an important but often overlooked aspect of overall wellness. Many users appreciate how this feature contributes to their daily comfort and health.
Environmental sustainability represents another significant advantage of Hule. The plant-based nature of these products means they typically have a lower environmental footprint compared to animal-based alternatives. This makes Hule an appealing option for those concerned about their ecological impact.
Hule is also recognized for its economic value. The cost-effectiveness of these meals makes nutritional excellence accessible to more people. The convenience factor cannot be overlooked either—these ready-to-prepare meals save valuable time while delivering consistent nutritional benefits.
The taste profile of Hule products has received positive feedback from diverse groups. The Yellow Coconut Curry variety, for instance, offers flavorful satisfaction while maintaining the nutritional benefits. This demonstrates that healthy eating doesn't require sacrificing enjoyable flavors.
Key Benefits of Hule:
Complete nutrition with 27 essential vitamins and minerals
High protein, low sugar formulation
Excellent source of dietary fiber
Environmentally sustainable option
Cost-effective meal solution
Time-saving convenience
Enjoyable taste profiles
Many users incorporate Hule into their routine when seeking to maintain consistent energy levels throughout busy days. The balanced nutritional profile helps prevent hunger-related mood changes and supports sustained focus during demanding activities.
George Pedley's 1966 Mysterious Field Discovery
In 1966, farmer George Pedley experienced an extraordinary event while working on his property in Tully, Queensland, Australia. While operating his tractor one morning, he heard an unusual buzzing sound that captured his attention.
Upon investigating the noise, Pedley witnessed a circular craft hovering just 50 feet away from him over a swampy area. The object hovered briefly before accelerating straight upward and vanishing into the sky.
When Pedley examined the area where the craft had been, he discovered something remarkable: a perfectly formed circle of reeds had been pulled from the swamp and arranged into a flattened disc. This formation measured approximately 30 feet in diameter and 2 feet thick, with the reeds arranged in a distinctive clockwise spiral pattern.
Local residents nicknamed the formation a "UFO nest" due to its swirled appearance and unusual thickness. However, this discovery would later be recognized as one of the earliest documented crop circles in modern times.
Pedley's encounter represents just one example in a long history of similar phenomena. While crop formations have been reported worldwide, the highest concentration appears in Wiltshire, England. These patterns range from simple circles to complex geometric designs and pictograms.
Common characteristics of these formations include:
Creation occurs rapidly, typically overnight
Association with strange lights (beams or orbs)
Recognizable, often intricate patterns
Formation without obvious human intervention
Historical records suggest crop circles have appeared for centuries. In the 9th century, a French bishop documented parishioners collecting seeds from flattened field circles. Oxford professor Robert Plot described and illustrated crop circles in 1686, noting they formed after flashes of light and animals avoided them.
A 17th-century pamphlet titled "The Mowing Devil" recounts a farmer witnessing a bright light in his field at night, only to discover a perfectly formed crop circle the next morning. John Leland, librarian to Henry VIII, also documented patterns appearing overnight in grass.
More recent documentation includes a 1937 British science journal with one of the first photographs of a crop circle, and a 1945 aerial photo taken by an RAF balloonist. In 1952, the US Air Force investigated circles in Kansas fields.
Despite thousands of documented formations, video evidence remained elusive until 1996, when John Wabe captured footage from Oliver's Castle in Wiltshire. His recording shows glowing orbs hovering over a field before a formation appeared below them.
The meaning behind these formations remains debated among researchers, with many believing they contain messages or communications of unknown origin.
Crop Circles: A Historical Phenomenon
Crop circles, mysterious patterns found in fields worldwide, represent one of modern history's most persistent enigmas. These formations appear rapidly, typically overnight, and are consistently associated with unusual light phenomena—either beams or orbs of light.
While many consider crop circles a recent occurrence, historical evidence suggests they've existed for centuries. In the 9th century, the Bishop of Laon in France documented parishioners collecting seeds from flattened circles in fields for fertility rituals. This represents one of the earliest written accounts of these formations.
Oxford professor Robert Plot documented crop circles in 1686, even illustrating several that appeared near his home. He noted two interesting characteristics still observed today: formation following a flash of light, and animals avoiding the affected areas.
Historical Documentation Timeline:
9th century: Bishop of Laon's accounts
1686: Robert Plot's illustrations and descriptions
1686: "The Mowing Devil" pamphlet describes a bright light creating a perfectly "mowed" circle
1937: British science journal publishes one of the first crop circle photographs
1945: RAF balloonist captures aerial crop circle imagery
1952: U.S. Air Force investigates circular formations in Kansas
1963: Astronomer Sir Patrick Moore studies formations with "spiral flattening" patterns
The Book of Enoch, discovered among the Dead Sea Scrolls, mentions "lightning leaving marks on the earth," potentially describing early crop formations. This suggests these phenomena may have existed since ancient times.
While thousands of formations have been documented worldwide, they appear most frequently in Wiltshire, southwest England. The complexity ranges from simple circles to intricate geometric patterns and pictograms with unknown meanings.
In 1966, farmer George Pedley witnessed what may be the creation of a crop circle in Queensland, Australia. After hearing a buzzing sound and seeing a circular craft rise from his swamp, he discovered a 30-foot circular formation of flattened reeds arranged in a clockwise swirl. Locals dubbed it a "UFO nest."
The first video footage of crop circle formation wasn't captured until 1996, when John Wabe filmed several glowing orbs hovering over a field at Oliver's Castle in Wiltshire. The footage shows a formation appearing seemingly from nowhere.
In 2001, a particularly significant crop circle appeared that seemed to respond to humanity's attempts at extraterrestrial communication. This formation appeared to reference the 1974 Arecibo message, which scientists had broadcast toward the Hercules constellation as a demonstration of radio astronomy technology.
Common Characteristics of Crop Formations:
Created rapidly (usually overnight)
Associated with light phenomena
Follow recognizable patterns
Range from simple to highly complex
Found worldwide but concentrated in southwest England
Animals often avoid the affected areas
Despite extensive research, the true origin and meaning of crop circles remain debated, with theories ranging from natural phenomena to human artistry to extraterrestrial communication.
The Mowing Devil and Ancient Crop Circle Evidence
Crop circles have a much longer history than many people realize. Historical documents from several centuries ago reveal early observations of these mysterious formations. In 1686, Oxford professor Robert Plot documented crop circles near his home, complete with illustrations. He noted they appeared after flashes of light and that animals avoided these areas afterward.
From the same period comes one of the most famous early accounts - "The Mowing Devil" pamphlet. It describes a farmer who witnessed a bright light in his field that he initially mistook for fire. Upon investigation, he discovered a perfectly formed crop circle, so precisely crafted that the farmer claimed no human could have created it.
Even earlier evidence exists. In the 9th century, Bishop Agobard of Lyon wrote about parishioners collecting seeds from flattened circles in fields for fertility rituals. John Leland, librarian to King Henry VIII, documented patterns appearing overnight in grassy areas.
The documentation continued into the modern era. A British science journal published reports and photographs of circles found in barley fields in 1937. In 1945, an RAF balloonist captured aerial images of unexplained formations. The US Air Force investigated circular patterns in Kansas fields in 1952.
Sir Patrick Moore, the renowned astronomer, wrote in the New Scientist Journal about his 1963 investigation of formations in wheat fields. He described "circular or elliptical areas in which the wheat had been flattened," noting spiral patterns and central areas that remained untouched.
Even ancient religious texts contain possible references to similar phenomena. The Book of Enoch, discovered among the Dead Sea Scrolls, mentions lightning leaving distinctive marks on the earth.
Despite their long history, crop circles remained largely undocumented on film until 1996. John Wabe, camping on Oliver's Castle in Wiltshire, captured video footage of glowing orbs hovering over a field around 3:00 AM. The following morning, a new crop formation was visible from the air.
Scientific Research on Crop Circle Phenomena
Crop circles have fascinated researchers for decades. These intricate patterns found in fields worldwide represent one of modern science's most puzzling mysteries. While thousands of formations have been documented, the scientific community remains divided on their origins and significance.
Historical documentation of crop circles extends much further back than many realize. In the 9th century, Bishop Abagar of Leyon noted parishioners collecting seeds from flattened circles for fertility rituals. Robert Plot, an Oxford professor, documented and illustrated crop circles in 1686, noting they formed after flashes of light.
The scientific study of these formations accelerated in the mid-20th century. In 1937, a British scientific journal published one of the earliest photographs of a crop circle. By 1952, the U.S. Air Force was investigating circular formations in Kansas fields. Renowned astronomer Sir Patrick Moore examined formations in 1963, documenting spiral flattening patterns and distinct structural features.
Most crop circles share several key characteristics:
They appear rapidly, typically overnight
Their creation correlates with light phenomena (beams or orbs)
They display recognizable geometric patterns
Many show evidence of spiral flattening
The epicenter of crop circle activity is Wiltshire in southwest England, though formations have appeared on every continent. They range from simple circles to complex pictograms and geometric designs.
A significant development occurred in 1996 when John Wabe captured video footage from Oliver's Castle in Wiltshire. His recording shows glowing orbs hovering over a field moments before a formation appeared - the first such documentation on camera.
In 2001, a particularly notable formation emerged that appeared to respond directly to human communication efforts. This followed the 1974 Arecibo message, which scientists had broadcast toward the Hercules constellation using radio telescope technology.
Animal behavior around these formations presents another scientific curiosity. Historical accounts mention that animals often avoid newly formed circles, suggesting possible electromagnetic or other physical anomalies worthy of investigation.
Despite extensive research, the scientific community has yet to reach consensus on crop circle origins. The phenomena continue to challenge researchers across disciplines, from physics to agricultural science.
Enoch, The Book of Dead Sea Scrolls, and Lightning
The Book of Enoch, discovered among the Dead Sea Scrolls, contains fascinating references to lightning leaving distinctive marks upon the earth. This ancient text provides one of the earliest documented observations of what may be crop formations.
These mysterious patterns have appeared throughout human history. The evidence stretches back centuries, with historical accounts describing similar phenomena. In the 9th century, Bishop Abagar of Leyon documented parishioners gathering seeds from flattened circles in fields for fertility rituals.
Robert Plot, an Oxford professor, recorded crop circles in 1686, complete with illustrations. He specifically noted they formed after flashes of light, and animals avoided these areas afterward. During the same period, a publication called "The Mowing Devil" described a farmer witnessing a bright light in his field that he initially mistook for fire, only to discover a perfectly formed crop circle.
Historical documentation continued with John Leland, librarian to Henry VIII, who wrote about patterns appearing in grass overnight. By the 20th century, more formal investigations began. A British science journal published photos of circles found in barley fields in 1937, while a balloonist from the RAF captured aerial images in 1945.
The formations range from simple to extremely complex designs:
Basic circles and geometric shapes
Intricate pictograms
Star patterns
Spiral formations
Common characteristics include:
Creation occurring rapidly (typically overnight)
Association with light phenomena (beams or orbs)
Recognizable, deliberate patterns
While Wiltshire in southwest England represents the epicenter for these manifestations, they've been documented on every continent and in most countries worldwide. In 1996, John Wayleigh captured the first video evidence while camping on Oliver's Castle in Wiltshire. His footage shows glowing orbs hovering over a field moments before a formation appeared.
Scientists and researchers continue debating the meaning behind these patterns. Most interpret them as messages, though their exact purpose remains unclear. In 2001, one formation appeared that seemed to communicate in recognizable language rather than symbols, marking a significant shift in the phenomenon.
The connection between the ancient Book of Enoch's description of lightning marks and modern crop formations suggests this mysterious phenomenon has been interacting with humanity far longer than previously recognized.
The First Recorded Crop Circle Footage
In 1996, history was made when John Wayy captured the first video evidence of crop circles forming. Camping on Oliver's Castle in Wiltshire, England, Wayy noticed unusual activity around 3:00 AM and quickly grabbed his camera. The footage shows several glowing orbs hovering over a field, followed by the sudden appearance of a geometric formation in the crops below.
This landmark recording came after decades of reported sightings with no video evidence. The Oliver's Castle footage revealed what many witnesses had described: luminous objects moving in coordination before a crop formation materialized.
Crop formations have appeared worldwide, but Wiltshire in southwest England remains their epicenter. These patterns range from simple circles to complex geometric designs and pictograms. While their meanings remain debated, they share common characteristics:
Created rapidly, usually overnight
Associated with beams or orbs of light
Display recognizable patterns and precision
Often appear in agricultural fields
Historical records suggest crop circles aren't a new phenomenon. The Book of Enoch from the Dead Sea Scrolls mentions lightning leaving marks on earth. In the 9th century, Bishop Agobard of Lyon described flattened circles where people collected seeds for rituals. Oxford professor Robert Plot documented crop circles in 1686, noting animals avoided the formations after they appeared following flashes of light.
A 1937 British science journal published one of the first photographs of a crop circle found in a barley field. More documentation followed, including a 1945 photo taken by an RAF balloonist and U.S. Air Force investigations in Kansas in 1952.
In 2001, a crop formation appeared that seemed to directly respond to human attempts at extraterrestrial communication. This formation resembled the 1974 Arecibo message, which scientists led by Dr. Frank Drake had transmitted toward the Hercules constellation. The original message contained binary code describing human life and Earth's composition, while the 2001 formation appeared to be a response to this cosmic greeting.
The video from Oliver's Castle represents a turning point in crop circle research, providing the first visual evidence of these mysterious formations taking shape under unusual circumstances.
Interpreting the Crop Circle Messages
Crop circles have appeared throughout human history, with documentation dating back to the 9th century when Bishop Abagor of Lyon described flattened circles in fields where people collected seeds for fertility rituals. In 1686, Oxford professor Robert Plot documented crop circles with accompanying illustrations, noting they formed after flashes of light and animals avoided these areas.
The mysterious formations continued to be recorded through the centuries. Historical documents like "The Mowing Devil" pamphlet described a farmer witnessing bright lights in his field before discovering a perfectly formed circle. John Leland, librarian to Henry VIII, wrote about patterns appearing in grass overnight, while a 1937 British science journal published one of the first photographs of a crop circle.
These phenomena accelerated in modern times, with thousands of formations appearing worldwide. The epicenter remains Wiltshire in southwest England. While formations range from simple circles to complex pictograms, they share common characteristics:
Created rapidly, typically overnight
Associated with beams or orbs of light
Follow recognizable geometric patterns
Appear in various crops worldwide
In 1996, the first video evidence emerged when John Wabe captured footage from Oliver's Castle in Wiltshire. His recording showed glowing orbs hovering above a field, followed by the sudden appearance of a crop formation.
Many researchers believe these intricate patterns are messages. A breakthrough occurred in 2001 when a crop formation appeared that seemed to respond directly to the 1974 Arecibo message. The Arecibo message, transmitted from Earth using a powerful radio telescope, contained binary code conveying information about human civilization directed toward the Hercules constellation.
The formation appeared to be a response to this cosmic communication, suggesting a potential extraterrestrial origin. This discovery has led many to view crop circles not as random phenomena but as deliberate communications from an intelligent source.
The Arecibo Response in 2001
In 1974, scientists utilized the powerful Arecibo radio telescope to transmit a message into space. This binary-coded transmission, directed toward the star cluster in the Hercules constellation, was primarily a demonstration of technological capability rather than a serious attempt at extraterrestrial communication. Given that the nearest star in the broadcast direction was approximately 25,000 light-years away, no one expected a response in their lifetime.
Remarkably, 27 years after the original transmission, an unexpected development occurred. In 2001, a crop formation appeared in a field near the Chilbolton Observatory in Hampshire, England. This formation appeared to be a direct response to the 1974 Arecibo message.
The original Arecibo message contained information about human DNA, our solar system, and a simple representation of a human figure. The 2001 crop formation mimicked this format but included altered information. It presented different DNA structure, a different planetary system, and a figure with a larger head—distinctly non-human in appearance.
What made this formation particularly notable was its precision and complexity. Unlike simpler crop circles, this formation contained intricate binary code that directly corresponded to the original message format. The formation was approximately 75 meters wide and appeared overnight, as is typical with crop circles.
Researchers examining the formation noted several key differences from the original message:
Original Arecibo Message
Human DNA structure
Solar system with Earth highlighted
Human figure
Population figure of ~4.3 billion
2001 Crop Formation Response
Alternative DNA structure with extra strand
Different planetary system
Humanoid with enlarged head
Indicated larger population
The formation appeared alongside another crop circle depicting a face, which some researchers believe was meant to represent the sender. Both formations displayed remarkable precision in their creation, with clean lines and accurate proportions that would be difficult to fabricate manually in darkness.
Critics argue that human hoaxers created these formations. However, witnesses reported seeing unusual orbs of light in the area before the formations appeared—a phenomenon commonly associated with crop circle creation.
The timing of this formation, coinciding with increased interest in SETI (Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence) programs and coming exactly 27 years after the original transmission, struck many researchers as significant. Whether authentic communication or elaborate hoax, the 2001 formation remains one of the most discussed "responses" in the study of potential extraterrestrial contact.
