The mysterious disappearance of Evangeline Laurer remains one of the most perplexing cases in Great Smoky Mountains National Park history. In June 1951, the 20-year-old nursing student from Cincinnati vanished during what should have been a pleasant camping trip with her father. After telling him she was going for a short afternoon hike west of Cades Cove, Evangeline was briefly spotted by a local near the Kott Family Farm around 3:30 pm, then seemingly disappeared into the wilderness.

The subsequent search operation became the largest ever conducted in the park at that time. Rangers and volunteers combed through miles of dense, treacherous terrain, finding only her discarded jacket approximately five miles from the campsite. Despite the enormous effort and tips pouring in from multiple states, the search faced significant challenges. The area where Evangeline vanished was described by park officials as "some of the wildest terrain in the Great Smokies," populated by venomous snakes and, according to some reports of the era, dangerous wildlife.

Key Takeaways

A 20-year-old nursing student disappeared in 1951 during a solo hike in Great Smoky Mountains National Park, prompting the largest search operation in park history.
The only evidence found was Evangeline's abandoned jacket located five miles from her campsite along the Rabbit Creek Trail.
The search was complicated by the exceptionally wild and dangerous terrain, which rangers described as some of the most challenging in the entire park.

The Early Days of the Incident

Evangeline Laurer's Life Before Disappearance

Evangeline Laurer was a 20-year-old nursing student from Cincinnati who disappeared in 1951. Standing 5'8" tall with brunette hair, blue eyes, and glasses, she had taken time away from her studies to celebrate her birthday with her father. The young woman was no stranger to the outdoors, having developed considerable experience with hiking and camping activities over the years.

Her family situation appeared somewhat complicated. Evidence suggests her parents were either divorced or estranged, with her father (a preacher) residing in Seattle, while her mother had established a home in Phoenix, Arizona.

The Camping Excursion That Changed Everything

On June 8, 1951, Evangeline and her father were camping near the Cable Mill area in Cades Cove, a picturesque section of Great Smoky Mountains National Park. Around 2:30-3:00 PM that afternoon, she informed her father she was going for a brief solo hike westward from their campsite. A witness named Lois Kota reported seeing Evangeline near the Kota family farm at approximately 3:30 PM.

This would be the last confirmed sighting of Evangeline. When she failed to return before nightfall, her worried father reported her missing to park rangers, which triggered what would become the largest search operation in the park's history up to that point.

The only significant clue discovered was Evangeline's topcoat, found about 50 feet from either a Jeep trail or access road along the Rabbit Creek Trail, approximately 5 miles from their campsite. Chief Ranger R.E. Merin speculated that "it looked as if she had got tired of carrying or wearing the coat and discarded it."

Father-Daughter Relationship Dynamics

The camping trip appeared to be an intentional bonding experience between Evangeline and her father. Given their geographical separation—with him in Seattle and her in Cincinnati—this birthday trip likely represented an important opportunity to strengthen their relationship.

Her father exhibited a certain level of trust in Evangeline's outdoor abilities, not immediately becoming concerned when she ventured off alone. He was familiar with what he described as her tendency to deviate from established trails to make "little side expeditions," something she had always safely returned from in the past.

This trust may explain why alarm wasn't raised immediately. However, the terrain in the Great Smoky Mountains presented significant dangers to someone unfamiliar with the Appalachians. Park officials later described the area where Evangeline disappeared as "some of the wildest terrain of the Great Smokies," populated with various hazards including venomous snakes like rattlesnakes and copperheads.

The Searching Expedition

Early Investigation Hurdles

The search for Evangeline Laurer in the Great Smoky Mountains became the largest rescue operation in the park's history at that time. Rangers faced significant challenges from the start, particularly due to the rugged and wild terrain of the area. Chief Ranger Merin noted that stepping off the trail placed someone "in some of the wildest terrain of the Great Smokies," making the search particularly difficult.

Weather conditions and natural hazards compounded these difficulties. While bears were present in the area, rangers believed they wouldn't pose a direct threat to Evangeline. However, they expressed genuine concern about venomous snakes, specifically rattlesnakes and copperheads that inhabited the region.

Physical Characteristics and Last Known Location

Searchers were looking for a 5'8" brunette woman in her early twenties with blue eyes and glasses. She was last seen wearing blue jeans, a blouse or sweater, a jacket, and low-top white tennis shoes. According to witness accounts, Lois Kota spotted Evangeline near the Kota family farm around 3:30 PM on June 8, 1951.

The search team found only one tangible clue in the initial days - Evangeline's topcoat discovered approximately 5 miles from her campsite. This item was located about 50 feet from either a Jeep trail or access road along the Rabbit Creek Trail. Chief Ranger Merin speculated she might have "got tired of carrying or wearing the coat and discarded it."

Community Response and Report Influx

Tips about Evangeline's possible whereabouts came pouring in from across Tennessee and beyond. Some reports suggested she might be in South Carolina, while others pointed as far away as Arizona. This widespread response demonstrated the public's engagement with the case.

The search team methodically:

Combed hiking trails throughout the area
Interviewed travelers who might have seen Evangeline
Searched through dense brush and off-trail areas
Investigated every credible tip received

Despite these extensive efforts, the searchers encountered significant difficulties in locating any additional evidence beyond the discarded coat, leaving many questions unanswered as the investigation continued.

The Unexplained Disappearance

Discovery of Evangeline's Coat

On June 10, 1951, search teams made their first significant discovery in the case of missing 20-year-old Evangeline Laurer. Her coat was found approximately 5 miles from her campsite, lying just 50 feet from either a Jeep trail or access road along the Rabbit Creek Trail. Chief Ranger Merin noted that the coat appeared to have been deliberately set aside, suggesting "it looked as if she had got tired of carrying or wearing the coat and discarded it." This discovery raised more questions than answers, as abandoning outerwear in the unpredictable mountain environment seemed uncharacteristic for an experienced hiker.

The location of the coat provided searchers with their only tangible clue after what had become the largest search operation in Great Smoky Mountains National Park history at that time. Search parties had been combing the area since June 8th, when Evangeline failed to return from what was supposed to be a brief solo hike from the Cades Cove area.

Environmental Challenges and Risks

The area where Evangeline disappeared presented numerous survival challenges. A National Park Service spokesperson described the region beyond the trails as "some of the wildest terrain of the Great Smokies." This rugged landscape would be difficult for even experienced hikers to navigate, especially without proper supplies or shelter.

Wildlife dangers presented additional concerns for searchers. While some media reports dramatically characterized the area as where "man-eating bears roam at will," Chief Ranger Merin expressed doubt that bears would pose a significant threat to Evangeline. However, he acknowledged that venomous snakes—particularly rattlesnakes and copperheads—represented legitimate dangers for someone stranded in the wilderness.

The absence of her coat further complicated Evangeline's survival prospects, as temperature fluctuations in the mountains could create dangerous conditions, especially overnight.

Possible Explanations and Conjectures

Several factors made Evangeline's case particularly puzzling:

Personal Background

20-year-old nursing student from Cincinnati
On a birthday camping trip with her father, a Seattle preacher
Experienced in hiking and camping
Described as 5'8", brunette with blue eyes and glasses

Hiking Habits

Her father noted Evangeline had "a tendency to turn off trail to make little side expeditions"
This habit, while seemingly minor, could be dangerous for someone unfamiliar with Appalachian terrain

Search Response

Tips came from multiple locations across Tennessee, South Carolina and even Arizona
Despite extensive search efforts interviewing travelers and examining brush, no further traces were found

The location of her discarded coat raises the possibility that Evangeline may have voluntarily left the trail system, following her established pattern of making "side expeditions." However, her failure to return suggests she encountered circumstances beyond her control. The coat's placement near an access road also raises questions about whether she might have encountered other individuals in the park.

Historical Insights

Key Chronology

The disappearance of Evangeline Laurer occurred on June 8, 1951, when the 20-year-old nursing student vanished during a camping trip with her father in the Great Smoky Mountains National Park. Around 2:30-3:00 PM, she informed her father she would take a short hike westward from Cades Cove. A witness, Lois Kota, reported seeing Evangeline near the Kota family farm at approximately 3:30 PM.

After Evangeline failed to return by nightfall, her father reported her missing to park rangers. This triggered what became, at that time, the largest search operation in the history of Great Smoky Mountains National Park. The only significant clue discovered was her jacket, found on June 10th, approximately 5 miles from her campsite along the Rabbit Creek Trail, about 50 feet from a trail or access road.

Date Event June 8, 1951 Evangeline leaves for solo hike around 2:30-3:00 PM June 8, 1951 Last seen by Lois Kota at 3:30 PM June 10, 1951 Jacket found 5 miles from campsite June 11, 1951 Media begins extensive coverage of the search

Terrain and Navigation Challenges

The area where Evangeline Laurer disappeared presented significant navigational challenges that complicated both her situation and subsequent search efforts. The camping location near Cable Mill in Cades Cove has changed considerably over the decades, with many trails and landmarks from 1951 either renamed or no longer existing on modern maps.

Search teams faced particularly difficult conditions as the area where Evangeline's coat was found represented some of the wildest terrain in the Great Smokies. Park officials specifically warned that stepping off established trails in this region placed hikers in extremely remote wilderness areas. Evangeline reportedly had a tendency to venture off designated paths during hikes, a potentially dangerous habit for someone unfamiliar with the Appalachian wilderness.

The search parameters included combing through dense forests, interviewing travelers, and examining every accessible area of underbrush, yet yielded minimal results despite extensive efforts.

Environmental Risk Assessment

The environmental conditions in the Great Smoky Mountains posed numerous hazards for anyone lost without proper provisions. Chief Ranger R.E. Merin identified rattlesnakes and copperheads as legitimate concerns for the missing woman, though he expressed belief that bears would be unlikely to harm her. This contradicted some media reports that characterized the area as one where "man-eating bears roam at will."

The absence of shelter, food, and proper clothing (particularly after abandoning her jacket) significantly increased the danger to Evangeline. While precise temperature records from 1951 in the mountain region are difficult to obtain, surviving overnight in the Smokies without protection would have presented considerable challenges.

Search teams were instructed to look for a 5'8" brunette with blue eyes and glasses, wearing:

Blue jeans
A blouse or sweater
Low-top white shoes

The environmental factors, combined with the challenging terrain and Evangeline's apparent habit of leaving established trails, created a particularly dangerous situation with limited chance of successful self-rescue.

The Vanishing of Evangeline Lorimer: A Chilling "Missing 411" Mystery in Great Smoky Mountains